Global Events · eTN Contacts & Team · Advertising · Submit Articles ·    

Mid-East Conflict

Gaza: Truth or consequence

Gaza: Truth or consequence
Image via keyholepublishing.com

By Hazel Heyer, eTN Staff Writer | Jan 07, 2009

“Jews and Arabs refuse to act as enemies!” yelled Jaffa activists late Tuesday afternoon at Ajami Park, corner Yefet and Dr. Erlich streets. They demanded immediate ceasefire and total withdrawal of the blockade. “After two years of the siege, in which Israel controls land, sea and air and defines the amounts of food, medicine, electricity and gas that can enter the Gaza Strip, the government has opted for a military operation that has killed over 500 and injured thousands. The Israeli government is trying to persuade us that the offense is actually a defensive operation to protect the citizens of the south and a reaction to Hamas' aggression – but the facts show us otherwise: the situation in the south of Israel is the result of Israel's policy towards Gaza and the inhumane conditions in which live all of its residents,” echoed Fadi Shbeita, Hani Amoury and Einat Podjarny.

Following the demonstration in Jaffa last week, the police and security services have summoned and arrested dozens of Arab local activists and public figures. Some have even been taken from their homes under police escort among them Municipal Council's Representative Omar Siksik. These individuals were investigated on unfounded trumped-up suspicions, such as the incitement of terror and the non-recognition of the state. “The sole purpose of these charges was to create an atmosphere of fear and political terror among the Arab Jaffa public. The harrowing parallels of such actions with oppressive regimes throughout history are apparent for all to see, and to us, are deeply disturbing,” said the three Jaffa activists.

Author of several books, including contributing for seven years to the New York Times, Chris Hedges recounts in “Lost in the Rubble” his meeting with Nizar Rayan, who Israelis killed in a targeted assassination on Thursday.

California State University politics professor Dr. As’ad AbuKhalil does not point a finger to just one party. This author of several books on the Mid-east including The Battle for Saudi Arabia: Royalty, Fundamentalism, and Global Power said: "This is probably the first open war on the Palestinian people launched with the direct participation and cooperation between Israel and Arab regimes. The turmoil in Arab countries from North Africa to the Gulf may destabilize those same regimes that the US has been trying to shore up against the wishes of their people."

Uri Avnery, founder of Gush-Shalom, the Israeli Peace Bloc recently wrote the piece "How Israel is Multiplying Hamas by a Thousand: Molten Lead in Gaza," said: “The ceasefire did not collapse, because there was no real ceasefire to start with. The main requirement for any ceasefire in the Gaza Strip must be the opening of the border crossings. There can be no life in Gaza without a steady flow of supplies. But the crossings were not opened, except for a few hours now and again. The blockade on land, on sea and in the air against a million and a half human beings is an act of war, as much as any dropping of bombs or launching of rockets. It paralyzes life in the Gaza Strip, eliminating most sources of employment, pushing hundreds of thousands to the brink of starvation, stopping most hospitals from functioning,
disrupting the supply of electricity and water.”

Avnery further added; "It was the Israeli government which set up Hamas to start with. When I once asked a former Shin-Bet chief, Yaakov Peri, about it, he answered enigmatically: 'We did not create it, but we did not hinder its creation.' ... [Mahmoud] Abbas was not allowed the slightest political achievement. The negotiations, under American auspices, became a joke. The most authentic Fatah leader, Marwan Barghouti, was sent to prison for life."

Before his death, the late Professor Edward Said wrote about Gaza in August 2002. He said: "Every Palestinian has become a prisoner. Gaza is surrounded by an electrified fence on three sides: imprisoned like animals, Gazans are unable to move, unable to work, unable to sell their vegetables or fruit, unable to go to school. They are exposed from the air to Israeli planes and helicopters and are gunned down like turkeys on the ground by tanks and machine guns. Impoverished and starved, Gaza is a human nightmare. Hope has been eliminated from the Palestinian vocabulary so that only raw defiance remains. Palestinians must die a slow death so that Israel can have its security, which is just around the corner but cannot be realized because of the special Israeli "insecurity." The whole world must sympathize, while the cries of Palestinian orphans, sick old women, bereaved communities, and tortured prisoners simply go unheard and unrecorded. Doubtless, we will be told, these horrors serve a larger purpose than mere sadistic cruelty. After , "the two sides" are engaged in a "cycle of violence" that has to be stopped, sometime, somewhere. Once in a while we ought to pause and declare indignantly that there is only one side with an army and a country: the other is a stateless dispossessed population of people without rights or any present way of securing them. The language of suffering and concrete daily life has been either hijacked or so perverted as, in my opinion, to be useless except as pure fiction deployed as a screen for the purpose of more killing and painstaking torture - slowly, fastidiously, and inexorably. That is the truth of what Palestinians suffer."



Comments


Easy target to vent wrath upon Ms Heyer - this is a conflict with victims on both sides:
Please read this...

Dear friends,

The bloodshed in Gaza is escalating −− the death toll now stands at over 600 people and rising, almost half of them civilians and over 100 children dead.[1] As Israeli tanks, airplanes and artillery bombard thickly populated urban areas, hitting UN schools yesterday, thousands more have been injured and 1.5 million terrified civilians have no escape from this prison−like enclave −− the borders have been sealed. Hamas continues to fight and fire rockets deep into Israel: 11 Israelis have died, including from friendly fire.

Our worldwide call for an internationally−guaranteed ceasefire to protect civilians on all sides has begun to ring out loud and clear, winning the support of leaders in Europe, the Middle East and beyond: hopeful outlines of a deal are emerging.[2] But Israel is rejecting a truce for now and escalating its offensive, while US President Bush is blocking a negotiated UN ceasefire, trying instead to impose a skewed alternative that could legitimize Israel's suffocating isolation of Gaza.[3]

Enough is enough: these civilian deaths can't go on, and we can't let Bush and co block a fair, negotiated ceasefire. 250,000 of us have signed the ceasefire petition, let's make it half a million −− we'll publish it in a hard−hitting ad in the Washington Post and deliver it in meetings with UN Security Council members −− follow the link below to see the ad, sign the petition, and forward this message to all your friends and family:

http://www.avaaz.org/en/gaza_time_for_peace/98.php?cl_tf_sign=1

Our efforts really can make a difference −− Israel's own foreign minister admits that international pressure, if intense enough, could ensure a ceasefire. As the international community debates and delays, civilians are dying by the day. The top UN official in Gaza says, "There's nowhere safe in Gaza. Everyone here is terrorized and traumatized." Opposing a United Nations resolution, Bush reportedly proposes to exclude Hamas from any ceasefire deal and leave Israel a free hand, something that would guarantee that the violence continues. That's why we're targeting incoming President Obama and US decision−makers, as well as the European Union and other international leaders, to pursue a fair and stable resolution.

To be lasting, a ceasefire must protect civilians and end all attacks −− Israeli bombings and incursions as well as the rockets Palestinian factions fire into southern Israel. International supervision is desperately needed at the borders, to reopen Gaza's borders and crossings for food, fuel, medicine and goods, to prevent weapon−smuggling which has only grown under the blockade, and to monitor and enforce the ceasefire on both sides.[4]

Hamas, which won elections in 2006 and now runs Gaza, suggests it will agree to such a ceasefire.[5] It should be challenged to live up to its word just like Israel. There is no military solution for either side −− it's time for world powers to step in, advancing a fair deal to protect civilians on all sides and let them live their lives in peace and security. Sign the petition now at the link below and send this message to everyone you know −− we'll publish it in The Washington Post and elsewhere, and seek face−to−face meetings to deliver the petition with the Obama team, the UN Security Council and European leaders:

http://www.avaaz.org/en/gaza_time_for_peace/98.php?cl_tf_sign=1

With hope and determination,

Paul, Graziela, Ricken, Luis, Alice, Brett, Ben, Iain, Paula, Veronique, Milena and the whole Avaaz team

P.S. We wrote to European, US and Arab leaders last week about our campaign, and received several responses −− now we need to escalate the pressure. For a report on many of Avaaz's other campaigns so far, see: https://secure.avaaz.org/en/report_back_2

Sources:

1. Associated Press: "Israel Shells Near UN School, killing at least 30" )5 January 2009(
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5ioi_0jtO9RjMwPNRoXNCnd...

2. "Gaza: outlines of an endgame", Ghassan Khatib )6 January 2009(
http://www.opendemocracy.net/article/gaza−outlines−of−an−endgame

Al−Jazeera: "Arab ministers hold UN ceasefire talks" )6 January 2009(:
http://english.aljazeera.net/news/americas/2009/01/20091522052418539.htm...

Associated Press: "Diplomats seek truce as civilian toll rises" )5 January 2009(:
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5ioi_0jtO9RjMwPNRoXNCnd...

3. Israel Today: "Israel rejects European, UN efforts for immediate ceasefire" )5 January 2009(:
http://www.israeltoday.co.il/default.aspx?tabid=178&nid=17938

Yediot Aharonot: "Israel examining international treaty to isolate Hamas" )5 January 2009(
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L−3650522,00.html

4. These parameters are advocated by a broad range of experts and policymakers. See for example International Crisis Group's Ending the War in Gaza report )5 January 2009(:
http://www.crisisgroup.org/home/index.cfm?id=5838&l=1

5. Reuters: "Hamas seeks truce but says lifting siege a must" )5 January 2009( http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L5111105.htm

Strikingly, the US Army War College has just released a substantial report supporting the view that Hamas can and must be brought into negotiations and is capable of sustaining a long−term truce, or even peace with Israel. Linked via:
http://ricks.foreignpolicy.com/node/10703

The inside story of the civil strife between Fatah and Hamas and the Bush administration's involvement in this debacle is best−told in The Gaza Bombshell, an investigative article published in the leading US magazine Vanity Fair in April 2008:
http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2008/04/gaza200804

This news item from November 2008 provides more background to the story of how the Israel−Hamas truce collapsed:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/nov/05/israelandthepalestinians

You are receiving this email because someone sent it to you via the "tell-a-friend" tool at Avaaz.org. Avaaz retains no information about individuals contacted through this tool. Avaaz will not send you further messages without your consent--although your friends could, of course, send you another message.



What does Hazel Heyer's Pro-Islamist propaganda have to do with promoting tourism?
Do you really expect to continue her "Reports" (hah!) and not drive away readership?
I truly do not expect you will print my comments.



Dear Eturbo News

I am attaching an article by James Taranto which appeared in the "Spectator - a British paper - this is to give some balance to your Hazel "Heil Hitler" Heyer's opinions (certainly not facts!). I hope you publish it:
And so now begins the second and most difficult stage. Inside�Israel, there is both determination and dread as tens of thousands of�Israel�s conscript army are called to the front. Untold numbers of these soldiers will lose their lives as the result not merely of the genocidal aims of Hamas (and its Iranian puppet-master) but also the indifference and pusillanimity towards Palestinian terror displayed by world governments over the past six decades of Israel�s fight for survival, along with the active encouragement of genocidal Islamists by leftists, Jew-haters, Muslims and useful idiots who were on such thuggish display yesterday in the co-ordinated demonstrations in British and other western cities.

Such people have made no protest at the bombardment of Israeli towns by more than 6000 rockets in the past six years, deliberately targeting innocent civilians. They have made no protest at the way Hamas has used Gazan civilians as human shields, situating its murderous arsenals beneath apartment blocks, in schools and hospitals and mosques in order to�maximise�the numbers of civilians killed (in order to manipulate all-too pliable western opinion). No, their protest only starts when�Israel�finally takes the military action aimed at stopping this genocidal barrage. �

The worst thing is the moral inversion, in which the murderous victimisation of innocent Israelis is ignored while their murderers are described as �civilians� when they are finally killed by the Israelis -- who are demonstrably taking care to avoid civilian casualties wherever possible. Tragically, civilians always die in wars; and unfortunately there will undoubtedly be more civilian casualties in�Gaza�� along with deaths among Israeli troops -- as the war goes on. But the frenzied misrepresentations, double standards and moral inversion fuelling a hysteria in the west which in turn can only incite more genocidal violence are simply depraved. Particularly striking in its malice is the way in which the treatment of wounded Palestinians in Israeli hospitals is ignored � while news of the barbaric behaviour of Hamas in�Gaza�s hospitals is airbrushed out of the picture. At WSJ�s Opinion Journal,�James Taranto�noted that a report of this scene in a�Gaza�hospital briefly appeared in the New York Times a couple of days ago:

Armed Hamas militants in civilian clothes roamed the halls. Asked their function, they said it was to provide security. But there was internal bloodletting under way. In the fourth-floor orthopaedic section, a woman in her late 20s asked a militant to let her see Saleh Hajoj, her 32-year-old husband. She was turned away and left the hospital. Fifteen minutes later, Mr. Hajoj was carried out by young men pretending to transfer him to another ward. As he lay on the stretcher, he was shot in the left side of the head. Mr. Hajoj,�like five others killed at the hospital this way in 24 hours,�[my emphasis] was accused of collaboration with�Israel. He had been in the central prison awaiting trial by Hamas judges; when�Israel�destroyed the prison on Sunday he and the others were transferred to the hospital. But their trials were short-circuited...
You won�t find that passage now on the New York Times website because, soon after it appeared, it unaccountably vanished into the ether*. Nor will many in�Britain�or the west be aware of�this:�

Dozens of Gaza Arabs are being treated in Ashkelon�s�Barzilai�Hospital�at the same time terrorists are bombarding the city. The medical facility, the largest on the southern coast, is in the line of rocket fire, and medical staff often have to stop caring for patients and run for cover during air raid warnings. The 500-bed�Barzilai�Hospital�has close ties with�Gaza�City's�Shifa�Hospital, Barzilai deputy director Dr. Ron Lobel told the Associated Press. �It might seem completely absurd, but we have the privilege to be doctors. Our medical ethics do not distinguish between patients. We treat whoever needs to be treated,� he said One Gaza Arab woman refused to identify herself to AP [Associated Press] because of fear of retribution by terrorists if it were known that�her two-month-old granddaughter is being treated in an Israeli hospital. �I am very sad and hurt. We want peace, not war,� she said as�Israel�began retaliating after hundreds of Arab rocket and mortar attacks, some of them lethal.
The moral inversion in the west is so egregious, so monstrous, that the better�Israel�is shown to behave the worse the vilification that rains down upon it. What other country in the world would show such restraint in the face of more than 6000 rocket attacks upon its citizens � 6000! � that it took seven years before going to war to put a stop to it? What other country would treat individuals � including proven terrorists � from that enemy territory in its own hospitals? What other country would continue to provide essential foodstuffs and other supplies to those enemies who continued to fire rockets at it? What other country, when finally forced to go to war to stop the attacks, would show such concern to avoid the loss of civilian life that it contacts the population in enemy territory -- even households containing identified terrorists � to warn them to flee from the imminent bombardment? And what other country would, for showing such unparalleled moral scrupulousness, be vilified and libelled as�Israel�is?�Israel�s behaviour is moral, legal and proportionate. This conflict is revealing just who is on the side of morality, decency and sanity and who is not. The President of the�Czech�Republic, who is also the incoming president of the EU, has emerged in the former camp, declaring stoutly that�Israel�s behaviour is both just and necessary.�France�s president Sarkozy, however, has called upon both sides to stop hostilities � a moral equivalence which effectively gives Hamas victory by requiring�Israel�to abandon the defence of its citizens. Similarly in Britain, Foreign Secretary David Miliband has repeated his call for an immediate cease-fire � while Prime Minister Gordon Brown, according to this�Telegraph�piece, has apparently complained to Israel�s Prime Minister Olmert that
too many people have died

Would that be, perhaps, too many Hamas terrorists who have died? Would Brown have preferred that more of them continued to live so that they could carry on murdering more Israelis? In startling contrast Farid Ghadry, President of the Reform Party of Syria, has�written:
We Arabs must be the ones to stop Hamas and Hizbullah, rather than support their demonic and twisted logic of resisting development, enlightenment, and progress of the region. Even when development and enlightenment stare them in the face, their instinct is to destroy them pretending to safeguard their honor, the mechanics of which supersede all else including a happy life of fulfillment and accomplishments. So while we abhor violence of all kind,�Israel's campaign against Hamas must continue to the bitter end not only for the sake of peace but also to help Arabs realize they have a choice: Destroy like�Gaza�or develop like�Dubai. Will this happen soon? Maybe not, but if a wake-up call and a nudge, once in a while, to pierce through the fog of deceit perpetrated by Syria and Iran is what it takes to see the light, then we stand by the West and Israel in the only hope that an Arab Renaissance in the Levant may actually have a chance of resurrection.

Alas, many in the west don�t stand with Farid Ghadry. They stand instead with Hamas. Whatever platitudes they mouthe, it is clear that they really don�t want�Israel�to survive at all. The moral dividing line in this battle is very clear. Those who stand with�Israel�are on the side of morality, justice, and civilisation. Those in the media and public life who denounce�Israel�for having the temerity to defend its people are the fellow-travellers of barbarism. Having done so much to embolden and strengthen Hamas and�Iran, who are playing them for suckers, they are continuing to stoke the fires of irrational hatred and genocidal hysteria. As Israeli soldiers die, along with the Palestinian victims of Hamas whether as �collaborators� or human shields, their blood will be on these hypocritical western hands.



As Ronald Reagan said: "There she goes again." Hazel "Heil" Heyer and her anti-Israel, one-sided diatribes have come so often that it is impossible not to assume this is the editorial opinion of E-Turbo News.

While it is true that any war is simply a failure of diplomacy, it is also true that there are times when you must resort to the physical in order to defend yourself. That is the case here, a fact that whistles right over Ms. Heyer's bigoted head.

There is no mention in her tracts about the 6,000 Hamas fired rockets that have plagued Israel for eight years; there is no mention that Israel is the only entity that has been willing to give up and has actually given up land to secure peace. Russia and the United States both still hold lands taken in long ago wars that rightfully belong to other nations. And let's not even discuss lands occupied by the United Kingdom.

Yet international pressure is constantly laid at the feet of Israel to give up more and more. At some point in time this mentality of concession must become finite. The Arabs must be willing to give something as well. The only thing Israel has ever asked for is peace and secure borders. This has been met with rocket fire and suicide bombers.

When Israel and Egypt were shooting at each other a truce was brokered with each being required to remain at the current lines and forbidden to move weapons into the border zone. Israel discovered, and exposed the fact that the Egyptians had used the truce for a massive reamrmament program.

The United Nations, United States and others told Israel to "get over it" and accept the fact that this had happened. Then Israel was condemned for defending itself.

While Israel only asks for secure borders, Hamas has as its stated goal the total destruction of Israel.

It's time Ms. Heyer and E-Turbo News got their collective heads out of the sand and saw the world as it truly is. And if this is a tourism oriented publication, stay with tourism and stop the anti-Israel bashing.


Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <h1><h2><cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><img><span>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • You may insert YouTube videos with [youtube:ID]

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image without spaces, also respect upper and lower case.

Premium Partners